The Evolution of a good trade? WHIR

[vrnole]

I offered:
B Favre & F Jackson for J Flacco & D Brown

He counter offered:
B Favre & P Thomas for J Flacco & D Brown

Good trade or should I counter with:
B Favre & P Thomas for T Brady & D Brown

My Team:
C Palmer
B Favre
M Turner
F Jackson
R Rice
P Thomas
J Forsett
R Wayne
R White
K Winslow
B Celek
P Crayton
N Kaeding
Vikings
Saints

His Team:
J Flacco
T Brady
L McCoy
B Westbrook
T Jones
D Brown
M Bush
A Boldin
B Berrian
E Bennett
K Walter
T Gonzalez
J Carlson
R Longwell
Ravens