i get roy williams, give manningham?

[CRob44]

i know manningham has done more so far, but hixon is now back as well as nicks and roy williams could heat up, i know i win draft value wise but what about the rest of the season. I know alot like manningham but i think he will have more games like his last game or even less but ill ask anyway


both leagues are 12 team .5 ppr

trade 2. i give michael bush, cassell, calvin johnson, i get joe flacco, mcgahee, gage


would start gage in calvin spot and start mcgahee in kevin smiths spot this week and then the flex spot in the future. hell gage has more catches then calvin

accept both or one or neither

[No-Show Moreno]

Trade 2 i would take.. Trade one is more difficult on one hand Roy Williams is a seasoned pro, and you wanna say go with him. But on the other hand you are excited to see what Mario can do. It would help to see your lineup but i think if your WR core is deep stick with Mario,if not go to Williams

viewtopic.php?t=451112

[wurmz07]

I would definitely trade Manningham for Williams.

No way would i touch the second trade.

[rdj3385]

I personally would easily take trade number 1. As far as the second goes, it does (as already stated) depend on the depth of your WR core. Flacco and McGahee are both pretty nice upgrades, but it all depends on how well you can fill the spot if Gage has a tough go of things.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=451125

[MadDog36]

Hate to say it but I wouldn't touch either deal I don't think.

[CRob44]

my team is
schaub
calvin johnson
ocho cinco
torry holt
chris johnson
kevin smith
greg olsen
kaeding
sf
wr/rb manningham
bench
bush,
j stewart, mendy
cassell


i could really use mcgahee i believe in the flex spot.Looks like im not gonna have a majority to agree to accept or not accept.

[CRob44]

bump