Starting Campbell over Rogers!? Am I Crazy!? WHIR

[Wags]

Since Rogers has a bye week in a week, I was planning on picking up a QB this week, that way I have some good pickings. Kolb was my leading candidate, but with McNabb more than likely coming back, Campbell is my guy.

But would I be stupid to start him this week? He put up great numbers last week against a sorry passing defense, and looks like he might do the same this week against Tampa, and he has Carolina next week....who also hasn't showed a lot of promise. Rogers faces Minnesota, which has been stout, but has also had an easy schedule...

Take your pick....Rogers or Campbell

Leave a link

[HskrPwr13]

Rogers. Campbell was hardly a stud against a weak Det pass D, and GB needs to throw to win.

[lugmetric]

Thanks for snapping me out of it. I'm going to pass on the trade.

For your dilemma-you have to play rodgers. he has 3 talented WRs, a talented TE, and is playing favre for first place in the NFC north. he will be pumped, they will have to throw to win, and he's a must-start until he proves otherwise.
campbell is capable of crapping the bed any given week, regardless of the opposition. who knows, the bucs might even beat the skins.

start the stud, blame the stud. start the 'sleeper,' blame yourself.

[P. Griffin]

Thanks for snapping me out of it. I'm going to pass on the trade.

For your dilemma-you have to play rodgers. he has 3 talented WRs, a talented TE, and is playing favre for first place in the NFC north. he will be pumped, they will have to throw to win, and he's a must-start until he proves otherwise.
campbell is capable of crapping the bed any given week, regardless of the opposition. who knows, the bucs might even beat the skins.

start the stud, blame the stud. start the 'sleeper,' blame yourself.

Serious...there aren't many QB's worth starting over Rogers in any given week, and Jason Campbell will never be one of them. Good luck