How's this trade? WHIR

[Frank Stallone]

I get:

WR Greg Jennings
RB Jerious Norwood

I give up:
RB Willis McGahee
RB Donald Brown

My roster (2 QBs & PPR/PPCompletion):
QB Matt Schaub
QB Kyle Orton
WR Randy Moss
WR Anquan Boldin
WR Eddie Royal
RB Maurice Jones-Drew
RB Ronnie Brown
TE Owen Daniels
FLX Willis McGahee
-----------
RB Fred Jackson
RB Donald Brown
RB Michael Bush
WR Earl Bennett
QB Seneca Wallace
QB Matt Leinart
QB Josh Johnson

[Moose484848]

Not a fan of Jennings

I would do it if you had Turner and needed a handcuff, but you don't so Norwood is just a throwaway... Donald Brown has potential and so does Mcgahee. Like I said though Im not a big fan of Jennings.

Can you help with mine??

viewtopic.php?t=451286

[bearsfanatic]

Honestly, I cant see that Id make this trade. LIke the other guy said, unless Turner goes down, Norwood is likely going to sit on your bench for the year. Jennings is a great WR that hasnt shown that yet this year and I know Eddie hasnt shown alot yet, I still dont think that your upgrade is going to help you that much. Having Burleson on your bench was the decider for me.

Offer him Brown (great potential) and one of your WRs maybe? Or consider giving up Jackson? With Lynch back hes going to see alot less carries than the past 3 weeks.

Gl with whatever you decide.

[Frank Stallone]

Honestly, I cant see that Id make this trade. LIke the other guy said, unless Turner goes down, Norwood is likely going to sit on your bench for the year. Jennings is a great WR that hasnt shown that yet this year and I know Eddie hasnt shown alot yet, I still dont think that your upgrade is going to help you that much. Having Burleson on your bench was the decider for me.

Offer him Brown (great potential) and one of your WRs maybe? Or consider giving up Jackson? With Lynch back hes going to see alot less carries than the past 3 weeks.

Gl with whatever you decide.

Jennings has two 100-yard games in three weeks.

He originally offered me Jennings + Keller, who I do love, but I countered with this. Return yards do count, so Norwood isn't as useless as he is in normal leagues.

And I don't have Nate Burleson?

[bearsfanatic]

Wow .. tired eyes I guess .. saw Bennett (whose also up and coming) and my brain read Burleson. Is this a PPR league? Agreed that Jennings has put up some yardage, but hes only caught 8 passes in 3 games .. though Im sure him being hurt in week 2 didnt help. 6 of the 8 came last week. Dont get me wrong ... Id like to have him on my roster none the less, but PPR makes a huge diff when looking at WRs.

Norwood with return yardage makes a diff as well. He has more value then if not for sure. You have a great TE as is, or Id have said jump on the first offer. Even though McGahee gets limited carries, hes the goal line guy, and I see Brown getting more involved every week.

I dont think its a BAD trade by any means, just not one I think Id make. GL either way

[MAXIMIS]

It is fair I'd call it pretty even. Do it if you want to but I don't see a big advantage.
Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=451313

[riggins]

i think its a fair trade, and in the end i pull the trigger on this one.