BIG TRADE HELP.......WHIR

[catch22]

12 team league.... .5ppr, start 3wr.....no flex

My team:
QB - Rivers
RB - Ryan Grant
RB - Reggie Bush
RB - Knowshon Moreno
RB - Willis McGahee
RB - Cedric Benson
WR - Randy Moss
WR - Vincent Jackson
WR - Steve Smith
WR - Antonio Bryant
WR - Jeremy Maclin
TE - Jeremy Shockey
TE - Heath Miller

I Give:
Benson / Moreno / Smith / Shockey

I Get:
Michael Turner / B.Edwards / E.Bennett / T.Gonzalez

[theckeriiii]

I would not do this trade. Benson has a great matchup this week and Moreno's touches are increasing. Which Steve Smith are you trading?

Turner is not a top 5 back this year and Edwards is no help. Bennett and Gonzalez have much upside, but I think you are giving up too much. Good luck.

[DerekR]

I think you pull the trigger on this one. I like it

[WhipperSnappers44]

Thanks for the help with mine....

I wouldn't do this trade at all!

Benson (whom according to my post I absolutely love) however, I most likely would trade him for Turner so that is really a None-issue right there. However, I like S.Smith better than Bennett and B.Edwards put together (even though Smith has been less then stellar thus far) and I also like Shockey this year as well. Plus you would be giving Moreno for free.

I just really don't like this deal for you and think you are giving up waaaaaaay too much! Don't do it!

WhipperSnappers44!!!

[The D]

I actually like it. However, im not sure Grant or McGahee will stay healthy all year, and your team now has WAY more quality depth then if you pulled the trade.

So I wouldnt make the trade because of that reason. Just not comfortable with those guys staying healthy all year.

[venus]

Don't like it either, think the other trader is getting the better deal on every player other than with Turner and that is debateable.

[benb18a]

I don't really like this deal for you. I would sit tight. Your RBs are pretty much the all-value team, save for Grant, who hasn't been bad. I say roll with that and Steve Smith, you'll be fine