I have the same decision and I am going with Hester myself. I think if Colston does perform well, it will be about equal to Hester's production this week anyway since he will be limited by the tougher D. So in my opinion, Hester gives the chance of about the same points without the risk of being shut down. If I were NO and knew that NYJ could shut down Moss and Johnson (two superior receivers), I would see no reason to try to force things to Colston when I have a plethora of other options all over the field. The only passing touchdown NYJ have given up this year was against Nate Washington, who was opposite of Revis on the field. You could argue that Brees is a better quarterback than Scaub and Brady, but really? It is not like Scaub and Brady are push-overs, especially considering their receivers are simply better than Colston.