Will this trade benefit me??..Should I do it??WHIR

[jonesy37]

Here's my roster

Flacco, McNabb (start 1)
Peterson, Rice, Parker, Bradshaw, Chester Taylor (start 2)
Wayner, Smith (carolina), walter, burleson (start 2)
witten
brown
cowboys

here's the deal

i get.....schaub/portis

for.....Flacco/Rice

leave link...WHIR..THANKS!!!

[drgonzo71]

I would do that trade. Shuab is steal for those 2

[stvmcd]

Take Shaub. Drop Rice. Anybody on Free Agency?

[seaner_v]

Here's my roster

Flacco, McNabb (start 1)
Peterson, Rice, Parker, Bradshaw, Chester Taylor (start 2)
Wayner, Smith (carolina), walter, burleson (start 2)
witten
brown
cowboys

here's the deal

i get.....schaub/portis

for.....Flacco/Rice

leave link...WHIR..THANKS!!!

i would do that trade in a second

[markulous]

Yeah I think you have to take it. If Portis stays healthy he'll put up the same numbers as Rice(or maybe better). And Schaub is a definite upgrade.

[Techcontroller23]

I agree with all of the posts lol. Just thought I would say that! Ravens have to play Steelers 2 times and that will limit both Flacco and Rice, so its better to pick up Schaub and Portis!

Feedback for my trade please???

viewtopic.php?t=452753#p3108777

[ultramagnetic]

I guess I'm in the minority.
I'd rather have Flacco over Schaub, and Rice over Portis. So I wouldn't make that move.


help w/mine?
viewtopic.php?t=452745

[stallion7734]

Don't like the trade myself, as you're really only getting Schaub in the deal since
Portis is now worthless fantasy-wise. Rice is going to have a great season & Flacco
will be a borderline QB1/2 for you with McNabb coming back this week.

[seaner_v]

portis is worthless fantasy-wise? since when?