Please evaluate trade?

[dgreco1602]

Antonio Bryant, Nate Burleson, Kerry Collins and Ray Rice for T.J. Houshmandzadeh, Terrell Owens, Matthew Stafford and Brian Westbrook
He also offered the same trade with addai instead of Rice and Steven Jackson instead of Westbrook or any combination of these players?

Non PPR
Not a keeper league.

We start 2 qb, 2rb, 3wr,1TE, 2K and 1 dst

I have cutler and Aron rogers on bye this week. And Stafford and Orton are my backups.

Non PPR
Not a keeper league.

We start 2 qb, 2rb, 3wr,1TE, 2K and 1 dst

I have cutler and Aron rogers on bye this week. And Stafford and Orton are my backups.

my roster is:
QB
K Orton
M Stafford
A Rodgers (R)
J Cutler (R)

RB
B Westbrook
S Jackson
D Ward (R)
J Jones (R)
M Lynch (R)

WR
M Manningham
P Harvin
T.J. Houshmandzadeh
J Gage (R)
T Owens (R)

TE
B Watson
G Olsen (R)

K
J Nedney
R Succop

DST
Broncos
Saints (R)

[RBManiac]

ppr?

keeper league?

what is your entire starting lineup and bench this week???

also to and stafford are better then collins and bryant.

you are basically giving away Nate, house and rice for westbrook.

If free agenst like

Massaquoi, finley, Hakeem Nicks are available then do it and pick those guys up asap.

[dgreco1602]

Sorry.

Non PPR
Not a keeper league.

We start 2 qb, 2rb, 3wr,1TE, 2K and 1 dst

I have cutler and Aron rogers on bye this week. And Stafford and Orton are my backups.

my roster is:
QB
K Orton
M Stafford
A Rodgers (R)
J Cutler (R)

RB
B Westbrook
S Jackson
D Ward (R)
J Jones (R)
M Lynch (R)

WR
M Manningham
P Harvin
T.J. Houshmandzadeh
J Gage (R)
T Owens (R)

TE
B Watson
G Olsen (R)

K
J Nedney
R Succop

DST
Broncos
Saints (R)

[ampant]

I don't like it. You are giving up a lot for Westy, who could blow up big, but could also screw you if he goes down. Rice is consistent. Housh and TO are both garbage this year. Burly is the Hawks WR to own.

[ampant]

OK I read that wrong.

It IS a gamble giving up Westy, but as I see it . . .

Collins = Stafford
Rice <= Westy BUT Rice is consistent and not an injury risk
Burleson > Housh
Bryant => Owens (Both kind of suck, but Bryant will likely end the year with more catches and yards)

McGahee has been losing touches, which is good for Rice. I think this doesn't do a ton to upgrade your starters, but significantly reduces the risk of losing a starter to injury. I do think Rice will be solid all year. So I might do it.

viewtopic.php?f=44&t=452963

[dgreco1602]

I am the one giving up Westy for rice? Are you saying that I should do it?

[dgreco1602]

Anyone else have an opinion?