NEED FEEDBACK ON THIS TRADE - WHIR

[jhawks823]

ight people. i need some feedback on this trade. i think its a pretty even trade and im getting the better end of it. lemme know what u guys think about it. the trade hasnt gone through yet but this other kid in my league said he would accept it. i think barber is solid n will play well once he returns and fitzgerald will turn it around as well. these 2 guys r studs. steve smith has been struggling n i dont see him doing will this yr just because delhomme is garbage. wes welker is good but i dont like that fact that he doesnt catch tds. and benson is nice but i think barber is just as good if better. heres the trade...

steve smith (panthers), wes welker, cedric benson for marion barber and larry fitzgerald

here both of our teams

my team...

qb - shaub, farve
rb - steve slaton, cedric benson, joseph addai, jerome harrison
wr- vincent jackson, steve smith (panthers), wes welker, pierre garcon, nate washington
te - vernon davis
k - carpenter
def - ravens, colts

his team...

qb - joe flacco, trent edwards, kyle orton
rb - marion barber, ladainian tomlinson, jonathan stewart, ryan grant, tashard choice
wr - larry fitzgerald, mark clayton, justin gage, ted ginn jr.
te - dallas clark
k - jeff reed
def - steelers

[RBManiac]

i think its an even trade for now, and barber is better then bensen.

[RBManiac]

you are losing depth at reciever.

try to pick up someone like massaquoi if hes available after you make that trade

[blb2397]

I like this trade for you especially if this is non-ppr because Welker wont offer nearly as much

viewtopic.php?t=453104

[diablo99]

I agree with the other posts. Getting Barber and Fitz is always a good thing. If its not ppr welker is a low end number 3. Benson i feel is losing steam and his best games might be behind him. Steve smith gets targeted a lot and could explode at any time but would rather have fitz.

Barber is involved in both rushing and rec which is a good thing. Fitz seems to be getting a lot of extrad attention and Warner i dont like at all. However, i make this trade and dont look back.

Again if its ppr i think twice about it. SMith and Welker catch quite a few balls.

Take a look at mine:

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=453091

[jhawks823]

yeh im not in a ppr league. im gonna make this trade asap. thanks

[clarkw267]

This is a great deal. Benson is garbage, and will come crashing down to earth. Barber and Fitz are both studs. Nice deal.

Help please
http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=453027