Braylon Edwards for Coles or Royal? WHIR!

[footballprincess85]

Hi there,

I'm in a 10 team dynasty league, PPR and points per yard as well as KR and PR yards

I have both Jerricho Cotchery and Braylon Edwards, with today's trade, I do NOT want both guys on the same team. I have been offered by another owner either Laverneaus Coles or Eddie Royal for Edwards. Which guy would you rather have on your team?

WHIR!!

[deepseacole]

I would rather have Coles this year however Royal is the younger of the two. Neither are that great but you do have to get rid of Edwards.

viewtopic.php?t=453131

[paco785]

Thanks for the help on mine. It's really a toss up with these two guys. Royal has done absolutely nothing. So I'd go with Coles.

GL!

[Haypress]

Royal has been a total bust, and who knows if he is gonna have a breakout anytime soon with Orton or not, it doesnt appear if they have much chemistry brother. If you have to get rid of Edwards, take Coles absolutely

If you got a min
http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=453023

[mm92280]

I have to disagree strongly with the others that have posted on this thread. Laverneus Coles is a player that is clearly headed downhill and appears like he might be near the end of his career. Eddie Royal, while a disappointment this year (which I blame largely on a new, inferior QB and a new, heavily run-oriented offense), is a very young receiver who has a long career ahead of him. He caught more than 90 passes as a rookie, so we all know that he has a lot of ability, he just needs the right QB and scheme to bring it back out of him. Keep in mind that this is a dynasty league, so you have to think long-term, as well as this year.

Long-term, there is no question that Royal is the guy. This year? It might be a push or just a very slight advantage for Coles. However, if a rapidly-aging WR like Laverneus Coles is truly the difference between your team winning your league championship or finishing in 2nd, then I will personally apologize for my bad advice at the end of your season. Until then, the answer to this question is Eddie Royal.