Need trade advice -- Decision today!!! WHIR=yes

[mrjack81]

Thanks for the help with mine. Hopefully he wants hester, cuz knox has way more chances to score on special teams. I would definitely say Williams for you. The offensive coordinator just said that he wants cadillac toting the ball 20 times a game, like last week. It's all about him stayin healthy, but it's worth the risk.

[cleaver596]

I think you go for Caddy. Being named the every down guy is worth something, even on an awful team. Look at harrison last week.

[Wags]

Put up Knox for Caddy. Caddy has more opportunities to carry the ball and that's about the only godd thing Tampa Bay can do right now.

Know won't get the touches like Hester will.

[Rabbit]

Good input, everyone.

While every major metric -- and most people here -- tells me to insist on Caddy, I've decided to "settle" for JStewart. Reason? I've already got one load back on a horrible team, SJax. And I'm not ready for the frustration of playing two guys with bulleyes on their jerseys.

Between that and Carnell's history of never playing more than 6 straight games as a starter before the next injury, I've decided that JStewart is "good enough" to hold down the RB3 slot in a 14-man league.

Thanks, guys.

[saemick]

Sorry i couldn't help prior to you making your decision. I can see both arguments, but either way, I would have made the trade.

thanks for helping with mine though