Westbrook for Manningham & Shockey? WHIR

[munstermann]

Just had another trade come through that I'm looking for some other peoples input about. Leave a link and I'll help you out. Just got Offered Manningham and Shockey in Exchange for Westbrook. Now I'm Pretty deep in RB, but I like to think of Westy as my #2 RB. I'm pretty starved for WR depth. Give my roster a look and tell me what you think about me pulling the trigger on this trade! Again, thanks for any and all advice.

QB - Matt Ryan
RB - Michael Turner
RB - Glen Coffee
WR - Roddy White
WR - Davone Bess
WR - Bobby Wade
TE - Jason Witten
LB - London Fletcher
LB - Daryl Smith
DL - Justin Tuck
DL - Justin Smith
DB - Cedric Griffin
DB - Michael Lewis
DP - Antrel Rolle
DEF - Eagles
K - Bironas

Bench:
QB - Kerry Collins
RB - Brian Westbrook
RB - Rashard Mendenhall
RB - Jamal Lewis
WR - Lance Moore
WR - Julian Edelman
WR - Austin Collie
DB - Darrelle Revis
LB - Jonathan Vilma
IR - WR - Anthony Gonzales

[schmidty]

No ... not even close for me. You don't need Shockey with Witten on board (except for the bye). And Manningham is a fringe WR ... his value is in doubt when the Giants receiving corps get healthy. Westbrook should command MUCH more, despite the injuries.

[MPappadato]

No shot. Westbrook's name value along can net you a much better package. Wait till he scores twice this week against dreadful TB