witten for mcnabb??

[bluto]

I'd be getting mcnabb...witten isn't putting up big #s yet and I need a better qb (palmer is my starter atm)...,

4pt tds, 25passing yds per point non ppr...think it's worth it?

fwiw shockey and winslow are both available on the WW.

what would you do?

leave a link and I'll help you...

[BALCO All-Stars]

I would have no problem trading Witten to get McNabb and then pick up Shockey, but Palmer should be fine. Maybe look to trade Witten to shore up another position.

[bluto]

yeah...pretty much all set in all other roster spots:

QB Carson Palmer
WR Reggie Wayne
WR Chad Ochocinco
WR Derrick Mason
RB Adrian Peterson
RB Ray Rice
TE Jason Witten
W/R Tim Hightower
BN Greg Jennings
BN Trent Edwards
BN Percy Harvin
BN Larry Johnson
BN Chester Taylor
BN Fred Taylor
BN Correll Buckhalter
BN Kyle Orton

problem is shockey is on a bye...guess I could gamble w/winslow...I mean witten is mostly blocking these day I think

[bluto]

Thank.....pretty much all set in all other roster spots:

QB Carson Palmer
WR Reggie Wayne
WR Chad Ochocinco
WR Derrick Mason
RB Adrian Peterson
RB Ray Rice
TE Jason Witten
W/R Tim Hightower
BN Greg Jennings
BN Trent Edwards
BN Percy Harvin
BN Larry Johnson
BN Chester Taylor
BN Fred Taylor
BN Correll Buckhalter
BN Kyle Orton

[Thor]

I don't think I would do it. You have an upper tier TE and Palmer and McNabb should post similar numbers.


viewtopic.php?f=18&t=453635

[bluto]

bump...my only choices worth considering on the WW now are shockey and winslow...thoughts?

[bazzy_51]

I'd do it McNabb IMO is a definite upgrade on Palmer and your TE options on the WW are nice. I do it and add Shockey, as a previous poster had stated also.