D. McNabb or D. Garrard?

[49ersavior]

I'm currently leaning towards Garrard coming off a big game vs. Tennesse, plus Jacksonville's offense has been money for me with Sims-Walker and Jones-Drew as well. Both have decent matchups being Seattle for Garrarb and Tampa for McNabb, with Tampa having the obviously worse defense. After this week I might go to McNabb but is it a safe bet to start Garrard with McNabb coming off injury?

[dude,micah]

i would be safe and play garrard but a fair warning that Mcnabb might go off this week he is hungry because of how good kolb has been doing

[jh2031]

I love Garrard again this week. Another weak pass D with injuries should mean big numbers for Garrard. McNabb is coming off a tough injury to the ribs and he may be uncomfortable throwing his first game back...I'd wait and see how he does this week before starting him.

[bleedtheblack]

Both matchups are nice.

I like McNabb a little more than Garrard. He is at home. Seattle is not good but it can be a tough place on opposing QB's.