Brees for Williams???? WHIR

[wpiano]

I just got a trade proposal of my Drew Brees for his Deangelo Williams. I countered with my McNaab for his MJD which he rejected and said "what if I offered someone else to sweeten the Brees deal?"

Below are both of our rosters, I'm hurting at RB right now with Gore and McFadden injured and my receivers and TE are pretty weak too. He is stacked at RB and is trying to upgrade his QB.

I'm a little nervous about both McNabb's health and Brees' recent performance. I think Brees has more upside, but McNaab should be a serviceable QB going forward so it might be worth it to get an upgrade at RB and at WR.

I don't know a lot about DeAngelo other than he loses some carries to Stewart and Carolina falls behind in games and has to give up the run.

What would a reasonable proposal be?

I was thinking something along the lines of my Brees/Holt/Winslow for his MJD/Ward/Clark (i doubt he'd go for that though) or trying to go McNabb for Williams straight up. Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated. Thanks

My Team
QB: McNabb
RB1: Harrison
RB2: Cadillac
RB/WR: M. Moore
WR1: Manningham
WR2: Holt
WR3: Collie
TE: Winslow
Bench: Brees *bye*
Bench: Gore
Bench: McFadden
Bench: Bush
Bench: Driver *bye*
Bench: Hester *bye*

His Team
QB: Cassell
RB1: MJD
RB2: DeAngelo Williams
RB/WR: Hightower
WR1: Bowe
WR2: Ward
WR3: Garcon
TE: Clark
Bench: LJ
Bench: Lee Evans
Bench: Fred Jackson
Bench: Michael Jenkins
Bench Kenny Britt

It is a 12-team league with 4 pts for TD passes and 1 pt for every 25 passing yards.

[wpiano]

bump

[MadDog36]

DeAngelo for Brees is a fair offer.

Come on McNabb for DeAngelo are you crazy? That's beyond wishful thinking.

Holt is barely rosterable anymore.

He is hurting at WR also.

You have some solid bye week options. He's probably looking for another WR to play with.

[wpiano]

Turns out MJD is a dealbreaker for him even if he gets Brees in return. I want to get as much Should I try for McNabb/Winslow for DeAngelo/Clark?
I figure he will probably reject that, but then I can sweeten it by offereing Brees/Winslow for DeAngelo/Clark

Or do you think I'd have to throw in a marginal player like Bush or Holt to get this one done?
i.e. McNaab/Winslow/(Hester or Bush) for DeAngelo/Clark

Am I hoping for too much here?

What do you think McFadden's value is for the rest of the season? Is he worth throwing in just to get the deal done or do you expect him to go back to a RB2 status when he gets healthy again?

Am I undervaluing DeAngelo?

[MWRtodayy]

i think you are undervaluing him. Yes he splits and carolina is down, but alot of people have him as undervalued. Stewart has been a target of injuries and coming off a bye, i see nothing but d williams tearing it up. If there defense can just hold off a little bit, the staff has delhomme as a interception prone so they would run it more often than pass. GL

also i think itd benefit you more than the other person for brees/winslow for williams/clark

[wpiano]

Yeah, turns out he won't trade Clark either, so I offered him McNabb/Holt for Williams/Ward, thinking he would negotiate up to one of my better receivers rather than holt. The offer is dead now though, he just accepted a trade with another team of Williams/Ward for Schaub/S. Rice.