Trade MY Steve Smith for HIS Kevin Smith??? WHIR!!!

[JaysFan]

Seems fair right?

12 Team 2 QB Re-Draft PPR League
(YES WE START 4 WR AS PER BELOW)

STARTERS: QB- Schaub, Hill
RB- Peterson, Donald Brown
WR- Jennings, Boldin, Steve Smith (NYG), Bess TE- G. Olsen
W/R/T- M. Wallace, Choice
BENCH: Jake Delhomme, Beanie Wells, EMPTY, EMPTY
D-Mikell LB- Laurinaitis, Curry, K. Rivers
DT-EMPTY DE- Robert Mathis, EMPTY
S- Adrian Wilson CB- J. Wilson, C. Bailey

[Wags]

I'm not sure if this would help you that much. Yes, Kevin Smith is a catching back, but this is a heavy WR league.

I would be happy with Donald Brown and my #2 guy. He's getting plenty of touches, lots of catches, and has been average nearly identical numbers as Kevin Smith. I think if you traded Steve away, you'd have to fill a really big gap.

I say no go. Help with mine? viewtopic.php?f=18&t=454512&p=3118041#p3118041

[LaRock]

Smith is a definite upgrade over Brown (although I like Brown's future). Could you sell a trade for Boldin instead? He's struggling but his name alone might do the trick. I'd just be a bit worried because Jennings and Boldin are both down a bit and if they don't return to form you could seriously miss a guy like Smith.

I don't think S Smith will keep up this pace, so it is a good time to sell high. I just worry about where your WR corps would be after that.

If you feel confident in Jennings and Boldin, then go for it. K Smith is legit. But if you have questions about your WRs you might hang on to Steve.

Good luck, and please see mine:

viewtopic.php?t=454516

[JaysFan]

This isn't a keeper league so I need Donald Brown to perform NOW. My WR's after the trade would be Jennings, Boldin, Bess and Wallace.

[thejusman1]

I say go for it. Kevin Smith is a great back and put in some claims for the new hot WW guys (maclin & miles austin) to make up for the loss of steve smith. i'd say depending on the level of replacement WR, you win out big-time, because production wise the swap favors you heavily.

help on mine? viewtopic.php?t=454537

[rmarnold5]

I dont think you can since you start 4 wrs. makes it too tough. Id keep smith.


help
viewtopic.php?t=454530