Good trade?

[union44]

Brandon Jacobs and Julius Jones for Cedric Benson and Ahmad Bradshaw.

Good trade or not? Tell me what you think.

[dblj9911]

Well to me it doesn't make sense to trade Bradshaw for Jacobs, to me it would be better if one team had them. But I like the Bradshaw and Benson combo better myself. Benson is one of a very few rb's who is the one and only man in the backfield and Bradshaw is slowly taking things over in NY.

[grandpa]

Yea, I'd rather have the Bradshaw/Benson side too- I just traded Jacobs yesterday during the games with Witten and Garcon for Turner and Mercedes Lewis- Jacobs is not the man in NY- Bradshaw is just too good.

[msusprmn]

Comparing Jacobs to Benson right now, I'd go Benson. He's the feature back and Jacobs is too dependant on whether he scores TD's or not. Plus he's injury prone because of the style he plays. Which leads to Bradshaw who's playing well with Jacobs in the line-up. Imagine what he can do when Jabobs is hurt. Julius Jones is a non-factor so its pretty much Benson/Bradshaw for Jacobs and someone who shouldn't be in your starting line-up ever.

Please help
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=454538