Slaton or P. Thomas?? WHIR

[ogaley]

I am thinking about trading my Slaton for Pierre Thomas. Please let me know if you would do it...

[THEOT]

I am thinking about trading my Slaton for Pierre Thomas. Please let me know if you would do it...

need more info, what's the rest of your roster?

[chrisjay84]

Based on the two names alone I would do it. Slaton is not producing the way he should be and Thomas looked for real the past two games.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=454566

[ogaley]

Just looking for opinions re: which RB you prefer for the remainder of the year. But here is the rest of my team (12 team league) start 1QB, 2RB, 3WR, 1TE, 1DEF, 1K

Cutler, Cassel
Forte, Slaton, Addai, L. Washington
Fitzgerald, Welker, Roy Williams, Percy Harvin
Carlson
JETS

[mm92280]

I think there is no doubt that Pierre Thomas will be the better back. I don't think Slaton will be a complete bust this year but Pierre is just a very good all-around back with plenty of scoring opportunities. You have to take the deal.

[THEOT]

Yeah I'd take PT, definitely. He's going to get the ball a lot.