Trade Help ---WHIR---

[umma10]

Standard Yahoo scoring:

My team:
A.Rodgers, B. Farve
D. Williams, R. Brown, R.Rice, J.Addai
A. Johnson, D. Jackson, J. Cotchery, S. Moss, S.Rice
B. Celek

Trade Proposed:
I give: D. Williams & D. Jackson
I Get: B. Jacobs & V. Jackson

His team:
M. Shaub, T. Brady
C. Johnson, B. Jacobs, W. McGahee,
V. Jackson, M.Sims-Walker, M. Manningham, B. Berrian
J.Shockey, J.Witten

Leave a link,
Thanks

[umma10]

Anyone?

[PAL]

I'm not sure this trade really benefits you. It's seems pretty even to me.
I think you'll lose a little something at WR, as Philly seems to be a little more high powered that SD right now. And Gates is picking up some more catches for SD. Although V. Jackson is still a stud and has really only had one less than stellar game.
I don't know when D. Williams will get back in to form, or if he will continue to lose touches to Stewart, but it seems Jacobs is on a better team with opportunities for more touches, even with Bradshaw in there. But I don't think the gains you'd get with Jacobs warrants this trade.

[monkeysee]

I would do it, I think you make out a little better in both guys.

[paco785]

I would not make this trade. Keep what you have. Although V.Jackson is a stud and has Phillip Rivers throwing to him I still like DJax better.

Please help...
viewtopic.php?t=454664

[SonOF]

D. Williams AND Jacobs have underachieved this year, but I do think Jacobs is more valuable. D Jackson and V.Jackson have both OVERachived this year, but I think V.Jackson is more consistent and more of a go-to guy than Desean at this point. So as someone else said, you improve at both positions (although perhaps slightly), so it seems like a good move to make. Go for it.

Please help me out if you can:
http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=454647

[TexasHammer]

I wouldn't make the trade. I really like Deshawn, and getting V jack in return isnt worth it to me.

[umma10]

Ok the trade has changed...He counter offered with the following:

B. Jacobs and M.Manningham

for

J. Addai and S. Moss.

Thoughts?