Mendenhall for Antonio Gates Trade?

[shupirates25]

My Team is:
Qb - P Manning, Garrard
Rb - Peterson, Gore, Bradshaw, Harrison, R Williams, Mendenhall
Wr- Marshall, Jennings, Bowe, Houshmandzadeh, Walters, Moore
TE- Carlson
Last week I traded Shaub, Reggie Bush, and Berrian for Jennings and Bowe.

The offer out there now is Mendenhall for Antonio Gates. My TE is Carlson. Should I make this trade?

[srlarson]

If there is a keeper option I say no...Mendy has way to much upside......

Not a huge Gore fan.....so now Mendy is your #2....so would want more the a TE.....even though it's gates.....

[THEOT]

No way, you should get way more than that and Carlson is a top 10 TE, don't give Mendy away for a TE, he's gonna be the man in PIT now.