Colston vs Roddy WHIR

[DemonDeacon]

1pt per 10yds rush/receiving
5pt bonus for 100yds rush/receiving
6pt TD 1-9yds
9pt TD 10-39yds
12pt TD 40+ yds
1 ppr

Strict roster rules 2qbs, 4rbs, 5wrs, 2tes, 2kickers, 2defense. We start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1k, 1d

My Team
QB- Schaub, Flacco
RB- Chris Johnson, BJacobs, Sproles, Joe Addai
WR- AJ, Colston, Roddy, Mason, Knox
TE- Heap, Jermichael Finley
K- Scobee, Lindell
D- Minni, Bears

So i feel like i have an amazing team in a league where elite WRs outscore top RBs and great depth at WR. That being said my RBs have been failing me miserably so far this year. Suprisingly Addai has played well, but BJacobs hasnt done well and outside of that one big game CJ hasnt done much either. Im debating trading Colston or Roddy and BJacobs for Ray Rice and John Carlson. Or Colston/Roddy for Ray Rice straight up

Who should i try to push, Roddy or Colston?

PS: Anthony Gonzalez is also on the WW and would fill out my WR corpse if i did deal one of my WRs

[da bears]

I would stick with what you have there. I don't really like those deals that much for you. Your rb's may be struggling a bit but they are really talented and I think they come around. If anything I would say try packaging Jacobs/TE for an upgrade at TE or trade one of your QB's to upgrade. You have a really solid team don't go too crazy when a couple guys are struggling.

viewtopic.php?t=454704

[latsprewell20002000]

Well i would rather have White over Colston. But you could try to get a RB and a damn good one for Colston and Jacobs. Dont trade CJ4.24.

[skones]

To be honest, I like Brandon Jacobs more than Chris Johnson. With how awful the Titans have looked, they're going to be throwing the ball more than they'll be pounding it on the ground. With that being said, I also like White A LOT more than I do Marques Colston just because Brees looks to spread the ball around to his receivers.

Take that into account, and I STILL am probably more likely to stick with what you have than make a major move. If I WAS to make a move, however, I'd be looking to flip Chris Johnson for a guy like Frank Gore (Who I LOVE), Michael Turner, or the underperforming MJD.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=454706

[Dr Answer]

Keep Colston - enough said