Who Wins this Trade? WHIR Guaranteed!

[bigmac41]

Team A
Flacco, Hasselback
Jones-Drew, Morris, Gore, Coffee
S. Smith (CAR), Ward, Bowe, Garcon
Gonzalez, V. Davis
Akers
Panthers DST

Team B
Brees, Cassel
Lynch, Westbrook, Bell, P. Thomas
Wayne, White, Bryant
Ryan, Boss
K. Brown
Jaguars DST

Team A trades V. Davis and Bowe to Team B for P. Thomas?

Who Wins?

post a link

[THE SWAT TEAM]

Depends on formats really.

If your league starts 2 RB's and a flex I would say team A. If it starts 2 RB's and 3 WR's like mine does I would say team B.

[riley yorkington]

Ditto to what the previous poster said, i'm assuming your league's the former with a flex. Team A definitely wins the trade, but i don't think B does the trade as Bowe/Vernon don't give him enough of an upgrade at either spot to justify giving up pierre.

thanks for your help with mine.

[bigmac41]

sorry, we start 2 rb and 2 wr. thanks for the feedback.

[briggs820006]

This is a Win for team A, no question. Granted B get's a WR to cover Wayne's bye and an upgrade at TE...but they'll be left hosed at RB. Team A gets a stud RB to cover MJD's and Gore/Cofee's bye's with good trade value after the fact. Team A will be hurting at WR, but they were going to have to pick up a guy to cover week 8 byes for Bowe, Ward, and Bryant anyway. And personally, I've always been down on Bowe, so if I had the chance to get PT Cruiser for him and a TE not named Whitten, Clark, Gonzalez, or Gates...I would jump on it! This is not a trade I would even remotely consider if I was team B.

Good Luck!
viewtopic.php?t=454728

[pony13ca]

Team A wins without doubt. I wouldn't do this trade if I was team B!!!!

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=454737

[Doughhead]

Definitely Team A. Pierre Thomas is a difference-maker; the others aren't.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=454738

[tfarmer12]

Agreed. Thomas is more valuable. TE's are a dime a dozen. To get a good RB, a WR and a lower tier RB would be needed at the minimum...

Help me out:
viewtopic.php?t=454742

[ShowMeTheMoney]

The team getting Pierre Thomas. He's a big time player in the best offense in the league. Team A still has Tony G at TE.

Help me out: viewtopic.php?t=454473. Thanks!