i am to trade Chris Johnson and Willie Parker for MJD and Santonio Holmes??? is this a good trade for me? i think it is, do you guys think MJD will continue his success more so than johnson?
i also have benson, ray rice, and coffee as backups...
Do you need WR help? MJD is solid, and Chris Johnson just had one bad week. I wouldn't be so quick to trade him just yet. But, if you can get MJD that would be an upgrade at the position. With Benson and Ray Rice in your backfield, you've got plenty of help. I'd say if you need the WR help, go for it. It seems fair to me.
Johnson and MJD are of equal value, Moss is far more valuable than Worthless Willie Parker. HOWEVER- do what I do and look at their matchups for your playoff weeks- THAT is what will make one or the other the better RB to keep on your roster, especially if Moss doesn't upgrade you at WR (and your WR's must be weak if he DOES).
Hags888 wrote:Do you need WR help? MJD is solid, and Chris Johnson just had one bad week. I wouldn't be so quick to trade him just yet. But, if you can get MJD that would be an upgrade at the position. With Benson and Ray Rice in your backfield, you've got plenty of help. I'd say if you need the WR help, go for it. It seems fair to me.
Hags888 wrote:Do you need WR help? MJD is solid, and Chris Johnson just had one bad week. I wouldn't be so quick to trade him just yet. But, if you can get MJD that would be an upgrade at the position. With Benson and Ray Rice in your backfield, you've got plenty of help. I'd say if you need the WR help, go for it. It seems fair to me.
You have that backwards. He only had one GOOD week.
He hasn't had above 10pts this season but once in my league (1 pt 10 yards 6pt per TD)
But do agree it might be better to hold onto him. MJD wouldnt be a bad trade thou
Yeah, Chris Johnson is not consistent at all. But, neither is MJD so far. The jags score 40 one week, and 0 the next. To me, MJD and CJ are pretty much a wash. So, this deal would come down to whether or not you need to upgrade at WR. If Holmes upgrades your WR depth, then I would go for it. If not, I see no reason to make the move.
That's a pretty equal trade. I'd do it, because Holmes could be a solid WR and MJD and CJ are pretty equal. However if you have a good record already, I agree with someone else about checking schedules for fantasy playoffs...I know CJ has an excellent schedule.
Cafe Home
Fantasy Baseball
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by priest31 » Tue Oct 13, 2009 7:23 pm 
