Drew Brees Trade..Am I giving up too much? WHIR

[NFL1527]

This trade was just proposed to me...

I give up:
QB - Tony Romo
QB - Carson Palmer
WR - Andre Johnson

I receive:
QB - Drew Brees

If you were me, would you accept this trade? He's pretty firm on this offer. If you wouldn't accept this trade, how would you counter? My roster and the manager whose roster I'm attempting the trade with are listed below. Thanks a lot everyone WH..everybody..IR


Here is my current roster:
QB - Romo, Palmer
WR - Andre Johnson, Roddy White, TO, Johnny Knox, Sidney Rice Roy Williams, Nicks, Anthony Gonzalez
RB - MJD, Frank Gore, Marion Barber, Tashard Choice, Reggie Bush, Sammy Morris
TE - Owen Daniels
DEF - Eagles, Jets

Here is the roster of the person who offered me the trade:
QB - Brees
WR - Vincent Jackson, Sims-Walker, Derrick Mason, Antonio Bryant, Kevin Walter, Manningham, Collie, Moore
RB - Deangelo Williams, Ronnie Brown, Brandon Jacobs, Jonathan Stewart, Buckhalter
TE - Tony Gonzalez
DEF - Ravens

[taw856]

Yeah it's too much, and to be honest with you I wouldn't counter. I like your roster. You have a legit high RB1 in MJD, two WR1s in Johnson and White, and a respectable QB in Romo with a good backup behind him. I think you can win more than few games with what you've got.

Mine: viewtopic.php?t=454766

[WaCougMBS]

You are absolutely giving up too much - I think anything more than like Romo and Roddy White for Brees and a throw-in is too much. Giving up those two QBs is a wierd thing to ask anyway, but he's basically fleecing you of two top-12 QBs and a top-3 WR for the best QB - that's a move I would not do in 1,000,000 years personally.

Some input please? viewtopic.php?t=454816