Would you do either of these? WHIR!

[Hamiltond18]

I play in a standard scoring head to head Yahoo league. We start QB, 2 WR, 2 RB, FLEXWR/RB, TE, K, DST. Here is my roster as it stands now.

QB - McNabb
WR- Wayne, C.Johnson, S.Smith(NYG), L.Evans, S.Rice, N.Washington, P.Harvin
RB - AP, C.Benson, L.Johnson, Hightower, sproles,

He proposed 2 trades. Trade 1: Mcnabb and Calvin Johnson for Brady and trade 2: Mcnabb and S.Smith for Brady. Would you do either of these? Leave a link and I would be happy to help with yours! Thanks.

PS. Here is is roster, let me know if you would counter with something else.

QB - Brady, E.Manning, K.Collins, C.Henne
WR - Jennings, Nicks, Gonzalez
RB - D.Williams, F.Jackson, Benie wells, Addai, willie parker,

[howhao]

no - brady is really not in sync with the receivers plus the o-line isn't providing much help. i am not saying brady is not a better qb, just not a calvin johnson better.

help please viewtopic.php?t=454832

[Hamiltond18]

bump

[reconsniper]

I wouldn't do it. I think McNabb is going to have good and bad days but Brady is not the same as he was a few years ago. I think they cancel each other out right now. I would stay put with McNabb

mine
http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=455101

[Vlad]

no.

[bigdog80]

I think you are giving up way too much. Brady has not been the Brady of two years ago and is having problems over throwing balls to Moss. I would rather have Brady than McNabb, but by throwning Johnson in the offer makes the trade in his favor. Good Luck!

Help! viewtopic.php?t=455141