Hakeem Nicks or Mario Manningham?

[jarobert]

Would you drop Manningham for Nicks?

From what I'm reading Nicks is legit? Will he overtake Manningham? Who's the better WR3 going forward?

[spark0901]

I was just about to make this exact post. Seems like Manningham has faded a little while Nicks is getting more looks. I'm in a dynasty league and just picked up Nicks while someone dropped Manningham. I'm wondering if I should stand pat with Nicks or grab Manningham. I guess Nicks has more long term value.

[zftcg]

I was just about to make this exact post. Seems like Manningham has faded a little while Nicks is getting more looks. I'm in a dynasty league and just picked up Nicks while someone dropped Manningham. I'm wondering if I should stand pat with Nicks or grab Manningham. I guess Nicks has more long term value.

I think it's really close and could go either way -- Manningham was getting the targets the first few games, and now it seems to be Nicks. One thing I don't like about MM is that he seems to have a case of the dropsies, which could push him down the depth chart.

A little help with mine: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=454909

[jarobert]

I was just about to make this exact post. Seems like Manningham has faded a little while Nicks is getting more looks. I'm in a dynasty league and just picked up Nicks while someone dropped Manningham. I'm wondering if I should stand pat with Nicks or grab Manningham. I guess Nicks has more long term value.

I think it's really close and could go either way -- Manningham was getting the targets the first few games, and now it seems to be Nicks. One thing I don't like about MM is that he seems to have a case of the dropsies, which could push him down the depth chart.

A little help with mine: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=454909

Well I also have Harvin and don't get points for return yards. Should I drop Harvin for Nicks and see how it all shakes out?