Thomas Jones or Ray Rice for Calvin Johnson or Roddy White?

[SacKings384]

Non-ppr league format. I have been offered Calvin Johnson for my choice of either Ray Rice or Thomas Jones. I have also been offered Roddy White for my choice of Ray Rice or Thomas Jones. I need a WR bad. WHIR

My team:
QB -Manning
RB -Ray Rice
RB -Forte
RB -Thomas Jones
WR -Berrian
WR -Colston
WR -Knox
WR -Clayton
TE -Tony Gonzalez

[freshlesh]

I'd trade Jones for Johnson. I think Rice will have a better overall year...

[beerman]

i go for r. white for t. jones.

[SacKings384]

Just found out that Calvin is hurt. I'm not sure about Roddy. He was awesome last season, but sans last game he has been awful. I do need another WR though badly.

[Swipe79]

I would trade away Jones, if you really want to make the trade. Johnson is out for a bit, and Roddy White might be coming around. Tough call, how many starters do you have?

[JoeyBallgame]

I would hold on to Rice move Jones. The WR is tough. Calvin has started off slow but I think his best weeks are in front of him. If you wanna take a gamble on his health, I'd go Calvin. The safer pick would be Roddy.

Please help: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=455079