Chris Johnson/Matt Schaub Trade WHIR

[bigdog80]

I was just offered this trade: His Aaron Rodgers, Marion Barber III, T.O., & Jeremy Maclin for My Chris Johnson, Matt Schaub & Anquan Boldin. I'm not digging the offer and would like to counter with this: His Aaron Rodgers, Marion Barber III, Andre Johnson & Chester Taylor (I have AP) for My Chris Johnson, Matt Schaub, Boldin OR Welker & S. Gostkowski (he needs a PK and his waiver picks are running very low). I could also add Kevin Walter in the deal somewhere as I probably wouldn't start Andre & Walter. What are your thoughts? Am I off a bit? Standard Scoring/No PPR. Here are both of our rosters: LEAVE A LINK!

Mine:
QB: M. Schaub (HOU), J. Flacco (BAL)
RB: A. Peterson (MIN), C. Johnson (TEN), K. Smith (DET), D. Brown (IND)
WR: A. Boldin (ARI), W. Welker (NE), B. Berrian (MIN), K. Walter (HOU), N. Burleson (SEA)
TE: J. Witten (DAL)
PK: S. Gostkowski (NE), M. Crosby (GB)
DEF: J.E.T.S.

And His:
QB: A. Rodgers (GB), D. Garrard (JAX)
RB: M. Barber (DAL), S. Morris (NE), F. Gore (SF), C. Taylor (MIN), L. McCoy (PHI), J. Stewart (CAR)
WR: A. Johnson (HOU), B. Marshall (DEN), T.O. (BUF), M. Austin (DAL), J. Maclin (PHI)
TE: G. Olsen (CHI)
PK: EMPTY
DEF: Bears