Chris Johnson/Matt Schaub Trade WHIR

[bigdog80]

I was just offered this trade: His Aaron Rodgers, Marion Barber III, T.O., & Jeremy Maclin for My Chris Johnson, Matt Schaub & Anquan Boldin. I'm not digging the offer and would like to counter with this: His Aaron Rodgers, Marion Barber III, Andre Johnson & Chester Taylor (I have AP) for My Chris Johnson, Matt Schaub, Boldin OR Welker & S. Gostkowski (he needs a PK and his waiver picks are running very low). I could also add Kevin Walter in the deal somewhere as I probably wouldn't start Andre & Walter. What are your thoughts? Am I off a bit? Standard Scoring/No PPR. Here are both of our rosters: LEAVE A LINK!

Mine:
QB: M. Schaub (HOU), J. Flacco (BAL)
RB: A. Peterson (MIN), C. Johnson (TEN), K. Smith (DET), D. Brown (IND)
WR: A. Boldin (ARI), W. Welker (NE), B. Berrian (MIN), K. Walter (HOU), N. Burleson (SEA)
TE: J. Witten (DAL)
PK: S. Gostkowski (NE), M. Crosby (GB)
DEF: J.E.T.S.

And His:
QB: A. Rodgers (GB), D. Garrard (JAX)
RB: M. Barber (DAL), S. Morris (NE), F. Gore (SF), C. Taylor (MIN), L. McCoy (PHI), J. Stewart (CAR)
WR: A. Johnson (HOU), B. Marshall (DEN), T.O. (BUF), M. Austin (DAL), J. Maclin (PHI)
TE: G. Olsen (CHI)
PK: EMPTY
DEF: Bears

[garretterik]

Lots of pieces here. Let's break it down. You are right his first offer doesn't work.
Rodgers = Schaub
MBarber < CJohnson
AJohnson > Boldin (or Welker)
CTaylor > Kicker

Tough call. CJohnson and AJohnson are the best players here. You take a hit at RB to gain at your weakest point WR. One thing to be aware is that both KSmith and MBarber have been dealing with injuries, so this trade will leave you very vulnerable at RB. I think there are more points for you in this trade, but a lot more risk. With both Tenn and Hou stinking AJohnson should outperform CJohnson. But, one hit to MBarber or KSmith and your fantasy football season could be over. Personally I would stay put. Get rid of your second kicker.

Help me:
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=455107