Chris Johnson/Matt Schaub Trade WHIR

[bigdog80]

I was just offered this trade: His Aaron Rodgers, Marion Barber III, T.O., & Jeremy Maclin for My Chris Johnson, Matt Schaub & Anquan Boldin. I'm not digging the offer and would like to counter with this: His Aaron Rodgers, Marion Barber III, Andre Johnson & Chester Taylor (I have AP) for My Chris Johnson, Matt Schaub, Boldin OR Welker & S. Gostkowski (he needs a PK and his waiver picks are running very low). I could also add Kevin Walter in the deal somewhere as I probably wouldn't start Andre & Walter. What are your thoughts? Am I off a bit? Standard Scoring/No PPR. Here are both of our rosters: LEAVE A LINK!

Mine:
QB: M. Schaub (HOU), J. Flacco (BAL)
RB: A. Peterson (MIN), C. Johnson (TEN), K. Smith (DET), D. Brown (IND)
WR: A. Boldin (ARI), W. Welker (NE), B. Berrian (MIN), K. Walter (HOU), N. Burleson (SEA)
TE: J. Witten (DAL)
PK: S. Gostkowski (NE), M. Crosby (GB)
DEF: J.E.T.S.

And His:
QB: A. Rodgers (GB), D. Garrard (JAX)
RB: M. Barber (DAL), S. Morris (NE), F. Gore (SF), C. Taylor (MIN), L. McCoy (PHI), J. Stewart (CAR)
WR: A. Johnson (HOU), B. Marshall (DEN), T.O. (BUF), M. Austin (DAL), J. Maclin (PHI)
TE: G. Olsen (CHI)
PK: EMPTY
DEF: Bears

[Mercury0021]

i'd stay put. I have shaub in my league, if he stays healthy for the whole year he'll probably be under only p. manning and brees in points. You'd basically be weakening your team if you trade.

[bigdog80]

How about My Chris Johnson, Schaub, Gostkowski, Kevin Walter For his Rodgers, Barber, Chester, Andre Johnson? Does this sound fair/maybe a little in my favor? Anyone else?

[bigdog80]

bump

[BLeezieLSU]

No way in the world I do this deal if I am you. CJ and Shaub have way more value than the players ur getting back.

Stay put my man, stay put.

Help me,

http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=455193

[suki7474]

id stay put too. Schaub is going to put better numbers than Rodgers if he stays healthy. Marion barber is dealing with a nagging injury so u dont know how effective he will be. Good luck

Thanks for helping me out in my thread.

[tjdoren]

I wouldn't make any of those trades. If you feel like you need an upgrade somewhere, try to deal Smith or Brown for another decent WR option.

Thanks for helping on mine.

[Dawinner127]

Sit still.

[dawg17]

Agreed with everyone else, your RB situation is good and you don't want to get rid of C Johnson + I don't think he would get rid of A. Johnson.

Please help me

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=455243

[SirGrotius]

Definitely don't do. He's trying to convert a Maclin WW pickup into something special, but he's not worth it.