Jacobs, Rice or Slaton - WHIR

[Stelly]

10 team, NON-ppr. 1pt/10yds rush and receive, 6pts/TD

I need one of these three:

Jacobs @ NO
Rice @ Minn
Slaton @ Cinci

Thanks, and leave a link!

[footballfan30107]

Of the 3, I'd say Rice

Jacobs and Slaton, although they may get yards, are getting no love at the goal line. Rice at least gives you a solid chance both on the ground and through the air..

10 team, NON-ppr. 1pt/10yds rush and receive, 6pts/TD

I need one of these three:

Jacobs @ NO
Rice @ Minn
Slaton @ Cinci

Thanks, and leave a link!

[Calix]

I see the NYG and NO game being a low scoring brawl between the tackles, as both teams try and keep the other offense off the field and run the clock. That being said Jacobs is a monster when it comes to this type of game, even if he hasn't produced stellar numbers this year YET. I see this as Jacobs coming out party, and racking up a huge amount of yards and a score or 2.

Rice is going against MINNY, and even though they are giving up some yards on the ground this year they just dont break. They will give the RB about 80-90 yds, but they will not let Rice into the Endzone for a TD. Look at the last 3 times that teams have got down inside the 5. Stopped GB 2 times and they had 1st and goal from the 3 both times. Then they stopped SJAX last week and forced an interception I WOULD never play a RB against MINNY if I had another option.

Slaton all I need to say is WTH happened to CINCY this year. They seem like the most focused team in the league right now and I dont think Slaton will do anything against them. It is up to Schaub and the passing game all the way in this game. They have to get up early or this will be a low scoring brawl, and Houston will be sorely pressed to even land a punch.

Help with mine plz.
viewtopic.php?f=19&t=455175

[kmb154]

I do like Rice, but that is because I have him also. But the above argument against Rice is a little off, McGahee will get all the Red Zone carries so I like Rice knowing this since he may get a REC TD from 20+ like last week.

viewtopic.php?t=455176

[Eightan]

Tough one. Rice against a tough Minny defense or Jacobs in a low scoring slugfest... thing is Jacobs has been lossing more and more carries to Bradshaw and as someone else, just doesn't seem to be getting the TD's.

I'd probably go Rice. He gets more carries and is the better RB. Plus, McGahee hasn't been vulturing as many TD's over the past 2 weeks as earlier in the season.

Please help viewtopic.php?f=19&t=455179