My Westy/Grant/Ochocinco for his Ward/Barber/Marshall? WHIR!

[jonzy91]

I'm in a 8 team keeper league with standard Yahoo scoring. I've been offered Hines Ward/Barber/Marshall for my Westbrook/Ryan Grant/Ochocinco. Westbrook is my keeper from last year. My roster is:

QBs: Eli Manning, Cutler
RBs: Chris Johnson, Westbrook, McCoy, McGahee, Ryan Grant, Lendale White, Donald Brown
WRs: Andre Johnson, Ochocinco, Colston, Bowe, Derrick Mason
TEs: Chris Cooley

We also use IDPs but that is not important here. Would you do this trade? I'm 2-3 and Westbrook has by far been a dissapointment so far...

Post a link and i'll WHIR.

Thx in advance,
Jonzy

[dawg17]

No way would I do that - even if Westbrook has been a disappointment you still have McGahee and Grant. Too early to get down on your roster because it looks fairly strong. Plus Cadillac is the main man in Tampa if that means anything and Barber is splitting with choice and Jones when he comes back. I think you would be getting hosed.


Please answer mine
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=455243

[jonzy91]

No way would I do that - even if Westbrook has been a disappointment you still have McGahee and Grant. Too early to get down on your roster because it looks fairly strong. Plus Cadillac is the main man in Tampa if that means anything and Barber is splitting with choice and Jones when he comes back. I think you would be getting hosed.


Please answer mine
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=455243

It's Hines Ward, should have made that clear. But I guess it doesn't really change your view...

[kiddragonsoft]

i wouldnt make the trade. grant is a top 10 rb and ocho is about as good as marshall this year.

[bstock123]

I don't think it's "no way", but I don't see any reason for you to do it. Grant is solid, if not spectacular, and Barber doesn't improve things over what you have. I think the WRs you'd get would be a slight upgrade, but not enough to lose Westy adn Grant. Having Westbrook is made easier for you to swallow because you have McCoy too.

Thanks for the help on mine.....