Tuff call...whats the better combo here?

[RBManiac]

whos the better combo in PPR keeper league, and why?

Eli Manning, and Jeremy Maclin

or

Matt Hasselbeck, and Greg Jennings


This trade just occured in my dynasty league, and there is a huge debate over it in my league right now on who got the better deal.

[204BC]

The way things have panned out so far I'd say that Manning/Maclin is currently the better of the two. However I think that Hasselbeck/Jennings has much more potential.

I guess I didn't really answer your question, did I. I'll try again.....

Both QB's are suspect for injury so let's not consider that. The Giants have had a creampuff schedule so far. It gets a lot tougher starting this week. Seattle is in a very weak division. Advantage: Hasselbeck.

Maclin showed some flash last week but has otherwise been rather nondescript. Jennings has not lived up to his billing thus far but GB has had some difficult matchups. He'll bust out this week. Advantage: Jennings.

I'm going Hasselbeck/Jennings.

I know it's a long read and confusing, but could you take a stab at this: viewtopic.php?t=455526

[RBManiac]

Responded


Bump

[taw856]

I like Hass and Jennings for this year and Eli and Maclin for the long-haul.

Jennings is a preseason Top-8 WR, and one hot week from Maclin against a subpar opponent isn't going to change my opinion on who the better value is for this year.

Eli and Hass are closer. Eli's schedule will get tougher and he's battling an injury, but then Hass is always an injury risk too. I think I like Hass slightly better but wouldn't fault anyone for preferring Eli.

Still, Jennings' side is the one to have for this year -- and Eli and Maclin being younger makes that side the side to have for the future.

Mine: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=455392