Drop Manningham for Roy Williams? (WHIR!)

[GiantFanatic]

So all this Austin chatter finally made the Roy Williams owner blink and he's dropped him to the wire. Wondering if I should drop Manningham for him...?

I'm high on the Giants, but Manningham is a WR2/3 and a little feast or famine. The question is do I hold him as a matchup play or do I roll the dice that Roy will have a strong second half as he fights to remain relevant and prove he's worth the money Dallas spent on him.

Thoughts? Leave a link and I'll reply in kind.

Thanks,
GF

[bigdog80]

Not sure if I'd drop Manningham so quickly for Roy. I like Roy, but him and Romo haven't seen a whole lot of chemistry. This worries me and I think since Manningham is apparently on a pass first offense, he is the WR to have. I'd stay put unless you drop someone else for him. Good Luck!

Please help with mine! viewtopic.php?t=455602

[spread eagles]

I would drop Manny for Roy. Considering that H. Nicks will soon take over Manny's spot imho.

[putsch]

I would do it. True Romo and Williams haven't got it going yet but he's still the #1 receiver and that fact can't be undervalued. By contrast nicks and hixon are likely to start taking more targets from manningham, and obviously steve smith.

mine: viewtopic.php?t=455353

[Fasteddy]

I would "In a NY MInute" as they say. Mario will have an occasional big play but you need setady points from a guy on the field with regularity and that th #1 WR.

Don't give up on Roy... get him while you can!

Help me back at:
viewtopic.php?t=455648