Trading Philly Defense .... Good trade? Help please WHIR!

[TheBambino]

I Give:
- Eagle's Defense
- Lee Evans
- Torry Holt

I Get:
- Santonio Holmes
- Packers Defense
- A waiver pickup - Likely be Santana Moss, Anthony Gonzalez, McNabb, Maroney or Lance Moore

What do you guys think

Heres my team:

Leave a link!...

______________________________________________________
10 Team Non Keeper - Points League

QB - Aaron Rodgers
WR - Calvin Johnson, Andre Johnson
RB - Michael Turner, Frank Gore
TE - Dallas Clark
WR/RB - Brian Westbrook
K - Jason Elam
Def - Philadelphia

Bn - David Gerrard
BN - Lee Evans
BN - Eddie Royal
BN - Donnie Avery
BN - Torry Holt
BN - John Carlson

[TheBambino]

Any thoughts guys>?

[TheBambino]

Help please!!!!!!!!!!!!............ Leave a link.. Ill get you back!

[THE SWAT TEAM]

I would do this. Holt and Evans aren't anything and Holmes can be good along with a WW pick up.

[dream_017]

My thoughts are this:

- why is it titled trading Philly defense - defense can be played off the waiver wire, the Packers at this point are not a bad defense themselves for use in the upcoming weeks.

- how does this help your team - I see you as needing RBs, yet you are trading and getting WRs. You have 2 injury prone RBs and a currently injured WR, I would be looking to upgrade or shore up those positions, which goes back to: why defense

You have enough WR help to get by, but with being able to start 3 RBs I would have as many as you can get your hands on

[bbk4eva]

I don't see the point of this trade. I would keep your team the way it is.

[jmkratt]

I am going to have to agree, I just don't see how this helps you. I would stay put with what you've got and ride it out. I see it as a risky maneuver and would certainly not do the deal.

Any help?
http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=456436

[Sex Panther]

I'd do that contingent on getting Maroney (your RB are a bit thin).

GB, Holmes, and Maroney far outweighs the PHI, Evans, Holt IMO.

viewtopic.php?t=456390

[TheBambino]

Im not sure Ill get Maroney.... I only have a 5th waiver pickup...... So is the consensus to get Holmes? I dont think I need an RB I can only start 2... and have Westbrook as a 3rd. Should I need 1, I could always trade....

What if I can get Ochocinco from him instead of holmes? Better?