Am I stupid to do this??

[byoung2beer]

My:

P. Manning
C. Johnson

For:

J. Cutler
A. Johnson
B. Westbrook

P. Manning
D. Garrard

R. Moss
T.O.
M. Sims-Walker
T. Housh


C. Johnson
T. Hightower
R. Grant
J Addai

T. Gonzalez


Baltimore
Green Bay

[moneyman18]

I think its legit, you are giving away a peyton for cutler which is a little bit of a drop off but you are getting arguably the best wr in football and westbrook for c johnson is pretty even...

[brown thunder]

I wouldn't take the downgrade at RB or QB

[Hoosierdad]

Wow, that is a blockbuster. Here's the question. Do you think Johnson will upgrade your WRs enough to overcome the hit at QB, and potentially at RB. I don't think you would be stupid to take the deal. The problem for you is TO has been such a bust, and I'm not sure it will get better. Houch hasn't been much better.

What's your standing in the league? Do you need to make a trade like this? If you are out of the playoffs right now, I say do it. If you are in good standing, don't take the chance.

help?
viewtopic.php?t=456406

[byoung2beer]

I'm actually tied for second at the moment but need to upgrade my WR corps!! I think I might just hold off..