Opinions on a trade!!

[Nortonfan]

Is this a fair trade or does one side get the better of the trade?

Team 1
QB Aaron Rodgers
WR Braylon Edwards
WR Steve Smith (CAR)
WR Mohamed Massaquoi
RB Ronnie Brown
RB Michael Turner
TE Kellen Winslow
K John Carney
DEF GB
BNQB Big Ben
BNWR Jerricho Cotchery
BNWR Michael Crabtree
BNWR Anthony Gonzalez
BNRB Carnell Williams
BNRB Willis McGahee

Team 2
QB Matt Hasselbeck
WR Wes Welker
WR Steve Smith (NYG
WR Donald Driver
RB LT
RB Larry Johnson
TE Dallas Clark
K Rob Bironas
DEF PIT
BNQB Kyle Orton
BNRB Marion Barber
BNRB Correll Buckhalter
BNWR Kevin Walter
BNWR T.J Housh
BNTE Jermichael Finley