Am I nuts?

[don.beaver]

Theres a guy in my league who traded me Benson for J. Lewis prior to week one to help me out. Now he needs help at qb and I could use a better wr. I have both Brees and Flacco, but we cannot seem to come to an agreement...

I offered him Flacco and Driver for Andre Johnson and K. Collins and he declined. Since I feel for this guy and feel guilty I got Benson so cheap I want to help him out.

I offered Brees and Driver for Kurt Warner and Andre Johnson. Am I nuts or would he be crazy to pass this up?

[don.beaver]

anybody...

[chguerin]

If it's a PPR league, I doubt he'll go for it. Not sure about the QBs available to him on the waiver wire, but Johnson is the best player in that deal.


Do you mind helping me out:

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=456646

[don.beaver]

It's a standard league, no ppr.

Johnsons better than Brees?

[sj1]

ur not nuts but ur not being fully fair. in all honesty both trades are "almost" fair. but u r taking away his star WR in johnson and giving him a gd QB. gd WRs have a higher value than gd QBs- simply cos there are less of them present. half of NFL QBs post gd totals week win week out. this means ure not actually 'helping' him out in anyway. if he's given u benson on the cheap, and u WANT to help him( imagine you had Lewis all this time) look for someone apart from his Andre J. and tbh if ur really there to help him out you should gain nothing from the deal- just like he didnt gain anything in pre week 1.
i dnt know the details but i think u owe him 1 ; )

[don.beaver]

What if I were to offer him Flacco and Cotchery for Warner and S. Rice. Is this fair?