Trade for MJD

[grover99]

There is a guy in my league who wants to make a trade. His only player I want is MJD. He has offered me this:

His: MJD and Earl Bennett
for
MY: Benson,Slaton and Mendenhall

It is a high performance salary dynasty league. We start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE and 1 Flex (RB,WR,TE) WE also start a def and kicker, but I won't list them here. What should I counter with?

Here are our rosters.

Mine: salry/#of years

QB: Cutler 4/4
Hill 1/1

RB: Portis 29/1
Slaton 2/2
Benson 4/3
Mendenhall 9/4
Stewart 11/4
Coffee 4/3
Harrison 3/1

WR: CJ2 8/3
Colston 14/1
Edwards 7/3
Crabtree 6/5
Bryant 2/1

TE: Davis 4/2

His:

QB: Warner 9/1
Leinart 7/2

RB: MJD 18/4
K.Smith 8/4
Ward 16/2

WR: V.Jackson 3/1
Bowe 9/3
Bennett 1/2
Knox 1/3
Maclin 3/3
Manningham 1/3

TE: carlson 2/1
winslow 5/2

[grover99]

bump

[MadDog36]

No dang way man. mendenhall is a top 3 dynasty RB (watch and you'll see). And giving up Slaton AND Benson. that's insanity.

You'd be raping your entire RB depth for a small upgrade over 1 of your backs. Not a chance in hades.

Stay far far away.

[grover99]

No dang way man. mendenhall is a top 3 dynasty RB (watch and you'll see). And giving up Slaton AND Benson. that's insanity.

You'd be raping your entire RB depth for a small upgrade over 1 of your backs. Not a chance in hades.

Stay far far away.

There is no way I would take the deal offered, but I was wondering if there was a decent counter offer to make, or should I just stay with what I have.