QB - Eli or McNabb

[Frump]

I'm having a pretty hard time deciding on who to start here. Eli or McNabb.

My gut tells me to go with McNabb agasint Wash, but after thinking about it Eli is going up against Ari and their horrible pass def. Washington is actually pretty good vs the pass, with only allowing about 170 yards a game. Then there's the fact that McNabb laid the stinker last week vs OAK.

So what do you guys think: Go with the gut choice (McNabb) or smart choice in Eli?

Just would feel, weird, starting Eli over McNabb (if that makes sense).

[Riden]

i go with eli I think the giants and cards are gonna have themselves an old fashion shootout

[wildsau]

Definately Eli vs Cards. As mentioned above this will be a real shootout.

Have a look here pls: viewtopic.php?f=19&t=457029

[abby]

No brainer: Eli of course.

[TruNinerFan]

Go with the younger Manning