Knowshon + Manningham for gates + simswalker WHIR

[Papa]

I absolutly love the fact that simswalker is putting out almost 20 + fpts a week, almost every week.
I want that.

So i figured i gived:

Knowshon (who i dont think is gonna keep correl buckhalter from starting for long) and
Mario Mannignham

for
his sims walker
Antonio gates

my lineup is in my sig.
This is his lineup
Qb: warner
Wr: ocho, Ward, Bowe, Sims walker, Patrick crayton
Rb: Deangello williams, Pt, Chris johnson, addai, micheal bush, laurence maroney
Te: Heath miller, antonio gates

opinions? is this a pretty fair deal?

WHIR

[ollie7585]

If you can get this trade, I say you definitely go for it. MSW seems to be having a breakout season, and Gates is a perennial top 3 kinda guy. Manningham will fall off some with the emergence of Nicks, and as you said Moreno is in a crowded backfield.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=457167

[skinsfan]

Why would he make this trade?