R.Mendenhall for Brandon Jacobs???.....WHIR

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

1 pt for 20yd rushing
6 pt for rushing TD
3 pt for >100 yd rushing

i know this is probably a dumb question and i'm pretty sure i already know the answer, but i wouldn't hurt to get the cafe's opinion.

should i trade R.Mendenhall for Brandon Jacobs?

qb: mcnabb
rb: a.peterson
rb: d.williams
w/r: f.gore
wr: a.boldin
wr: r.white
te: o.daniels
def: ravens
k: n.keading
bn: j.flacco
bn: r.mendenhall
bn: c.portis
bn: a.bradshaw
bn: TO
bn: r.williams
bn: k.winslow

[JoeyBallgame]

With your team, doesn't look like you would be starting either in any situation. Based on value and upside alone I would do this deal. Jacobs has been a disappointment, but if he hits his stride he could be a late season sleeper for you. And with FWP coming back he'll be taking touches away from Mendenhall.

Please help: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=457163

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

bump....this trade offer is about to expire

[danielgreen091]

I would do the deal. Jacobs is going to start getting more TDs sooner rather than later IMHO. As the other poster said, you wont be starting either one so you can afford to gamble. This is a perfect example of selling high and buying low.

Help me viewtopic.php?f=18&t=457014

[ollie7585]

Is this a dynasty/keeper league? I see Mendenhall having more value long-term whereas Jacobs would have more value this season. Depending on the league set-up I could see you going either way.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=457167