favre or mcnabb?

[Spanky994]

favre at Pitts
Mcnabb at Wash

[NYjets18241]

Favre, its a tough one but mcnabband the eagles have pretection problems and Washington pash D is legit. Even though Troy Palumalu will be back i doubt he will be 100%. Favre has the protection, receivers, and running game.

[jh2031]

I know every expert is saying bench McNabb but with Washington in meltdown mode...I'd take a chance and start him. I doubt McNabb will have 0 TD's in 2 weeks. He wants to improve off of his bad game against OAK.

[kingmike74]

Touch call !

In 15 career games v.s. WAS, Mcnabb 23 TD's passing and 3 rushing, so you can say that he is due for 1.5 or so TD's this week. Mcnabb's last 2 starts v.s. WAS have produced 0 TD's.

Favre career v.s. PIT has 1 start for 0 TD's and 1 INT.

As a McNabb & Favre owner in 2 diff leagues, I would slightly give the edge to Favre, unless your league has a huge penalty for INT's, like minus 3 or above, then I would go McNabb.



I need advice on Favre also
viewtopic.php?f=19&t=457256

[Spanky994]

thanks all
I lost last week cause I played mcnabb against the lowly raiders instead of Favre in what turned out to be a shootout with Baltimore...
I think I will try favre again....although I do like to have someone on Monday night....just seems to add more hope if I need points.....

I play my son this week....so if I lose that's ok...(yeah right)