KSmith for McNabb? WHIR

[MotorCityKitties]

Non-PPR, standard settings

QB: Schaub
RB: DWill
RB: Jacobs
WR: Moss (Bye 8)
WR: Ocho (Bye 8)
WR: Moore
TE: Gates
K: Kris Brown
DEF: Pats (Bye 8)
BN: RRice
BN: KSmith
BN: Leon Washington
BN: AGonzalez
BN: Cowboys
BN: Shaun Hill

I just traded for Brandon Jacobs and I've been trying to move a RB for a WR to cover for my week 8 bye problem with wideouts. However, another owner has proposed Kevin Smith for Donovan McNabb. This would help out a lot with Schaub's week 10 bye. Then I could drop Hill for a decent WR for week 8. There are a couple teams that could use a QB so I would try to trade a QB after week 10. Do it?

[rockernc23]

I don't like it. Trading K.Smith just for a bye week QB isn't what I would do. You may think you can dangle McNabb later but unless there's an injury to a QB and you have a desperate owner, you may get stuck with him. It would be a gamble.

Please replay to my post

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=457261

[MotorCityKitties]

Bump

[MotorCityKitties]

Bump, Please.

Leave a link, I will respond.

[DemonDeacon]

ya dude this trade doesnt make any sense at all for you

[ehose2110]

Agree with everyone else. You can do a lot better than getting McNabb for KSmith

[cmust]

This trade should NOT happen! Look for other options for your QB bye.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=457363

[kira]

I think K.smith should have a better second half when calvin johnson/stafford comes back, and the schedule is not as brutal as in the first half