Trade Marshall for Gates?

[login]

I got offered Antonio Gates for my Brandon Marshall. Should I accept this trade?

________________
10 Team CBS H2H:

QB - P. Manning
RB - R. Rice
RB - F. Gore
WR - R. White
WR - B. Marshall
WR - D. Jackson
TE - J. Shockey
RB/WR - L. Washington
K - R. Longwell
BN - J. Cutler
BN - F. Jones
BN - J. Cotchery
BN - G. Coffee
BN - H. Nicks
BN - L. Evans
BN - B. Wells
BN - J. Jones

[login]

BUMP

Leave a link, I'll help u out.

[login]

HELLO this site sux these days. No responses to any questions.

[The U]

that is a very true statement! I've used this site for many years now for extra help and to have other people's opinions...but not much HELP at all this year!

[The U]

I would say no to this trade, Gates is a better TE than shockey, but if you trade away Marshall youare left with White( still waiting) and Cotchery(injured)

[iky]

I would take this trade in a heartbeat.

[DemonDeacon]

that is a very true statement! I've used this site for many years now for extra help and to have other people's opinions...but not much HELP at all this year!

the best way to get help is to help others... as you've only posted 104 times in 3years im assuming that you only ask for help and never dish it out...

i wouldnt do this trade.

[iky]

I would say no to this trade, Gates is a better TE than shockey, but if you trade away Marshall youare left with White( still waiting) and Cotchery(injured)

Stop complaining dude, and start helping yourself. I maybe ask 1-2 start questions or if im completely stuck, but I'm here every week at least answering to somebody who has 0 replies. And if you got no replies there is a reason for it, your question is just dumb. There are dudes here who just list their line up and headline it "Choose 3 WRs to start" And after reading through the post you find out the dude is not really sure about his 2nd RB, and his Defense is so iffy so pweeeze, smart dudes, set my line-up for me. Or those questions about 2 different leagues. I mean most of the regs here are very open and eager to help you, but know your limits. And start helping others yourself, rather then always asking for help!
Excuse me going off, but that's why nobody helps anymore.