Trade Kevin Smith for Steve Smith (Car) & Beanie Wells? WHIR

[kemper5]

12 team ppr league, 6 pt td's...

Trade my Kevin Smith -Det. For Steve Smith(car) & Chris beanie Wells?

Here is what my team would look like

QB Romo
RB MJD
RB Lynch
WR Jennings
WR Ward
WR Steve Smith (car)
Flex Witten
K Gostowski
D Pitt

BENCH
RB Beanie Wells
RB Mcgahee
TE Finley
WR Mike Wallace
WR Nate Washington
D Colts

[rockernc23]

That's a tough one. The Carolina passing game is awful but S.Smith is a stud. Problem is there's nobody else to help him @ the 2nd receiver position or TE. I live in Charlotte and he's really frustrated. They are such a running team and his production stems from the play action. Problem is their line hasn't played as well and the running game has been inconsistent. Delhomme is very erratic. If you're a gambler do the deal hoping Smith's talent will overcome and Wells becomes more prominent in the offense. However K. Smith is the more safe bet when Stafford and Calvin Johnson are in the line up. Sorry I just probably confused things more for you. Please respond to my below post.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=457261

[kemper5]

Anyone else?

[football00247]

I dont think I would do this deal. Smith is a stud but their offense is terrible. Plus he does need someone to get him the ball. This also would leave kinda line at RB. Stick with K Smith he is the main guy there. Thanks for helping on mine

[ImTheWhiz]

I would hang on to one of the only true RB ones in the league...Wells is at best sharing time with Hightower, but probably not goal-line carries and Delhomme is horrible.

Th on mine

[Go Skins!]

I'd do it. You have the RB depth and Smith would definately be an upgrade over your other WRs on your bench. Plus, you got to think playoff matchups here soon. Week's 15 and 16 (common playoff weeks), AZ plays Detroit and St Louis respectively.

I have Forte (who plays Balt and Min in weeks 15/16) on my best team, and I would be so tempted to start Beanie over him if I had him on my team for those weeks!

Make the trade!!

[kemper5]

I rejected it, when K.Smith has the Rams, Seahawks,Browns,Packers & Bengals coming up ....his future looks better..Thanks for the replys!

[Hogan]

I'd say no, Car offense has been off all year and Kevin Smith is a great ppr back. Much better than Lynch in my opinion because Lyngh splits with Jackson. Say no

[Mr.Cosi]

Don't do it. Keep K SMith. Wells is splitting with Hightower and Arizona is a pass first team so thats a con right there. Delhomme has ben getting rocked so that doesn't help S Smith too much.

[danielgreen091]

I wouldnt do this deal