Who would you rather have Matt Ryan or Carson Palmer...

[Shortym006]

I have Carson Palmer and D McNabb.

I am loaded at wide-out and was just offered Palmer and TJ Houshmanzadeh for Matt Ryan.

Am I wrong to think this deal would only be worth doing if it was for McNabb?

[wedgedbacks]

Ryan hasn't exactly been lighting it up, I'd take Palmer and the icing that is Housh over Ryan any day of the week. I feel that McNabb would be the option to get rid of, but again, Ryan's a marginal starter.

Help here?

viewtopic.php?t=457901

[Shortym006]

bump

[The U]

I would say Carson this year. Housh and Ryan are not elite this year...but havent been terrible either and you are loaded at WR. I wouldn't do this.