Advice needed on trade offer

[bassackwards]

In a 10 team league - pretty much standard scoring (no ppr) - I have been offered the following trade - My McNabb and Chris Johnson for his Peyton Manning. It seem like this is a bit much to give but it may upgrade my starters...what do you all think? Or do you think my team is strong enough for the second half and hopefully playoffs. I could also pick up Jamaal Charles off the wire to fill the roster spot and give more depth at RB. Thanks in advance for any advice and I would be glad to give my opinion on your questions in return!

We start 1 QB - 1 RB - 2 WR - 1 TE - 1 FLEX - 1 K - 1 DST

E Manning QB
D McNabb QB
M Lynch RB
S Jackson RB
C Johnson RB
R Rice RB
C Ochocinco WR
R Moss WR
V Jackson WR
M Austin WR
G Olsen TE
H Miller TE
L Tynes K
Minnesota DST

[rockernc23]

That's a lot. You need to get a rb2 as well or I would pass.

SEE MINE
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=457921

[bale]

I don't think you need this trade. McNabb/Eli should be fine the rest of the year, and you can alternate them based on matchups. I worry about any of the Colts come FFB playoff time. I think they will be rested and not used as much. Your RBs are pretty sweet as they are and should carry you far.

[MotorCityKitties]

That's a terrible trade for you. Sit tight with eli and mcnabb.