Megatron for Jennings - Keeper League (WHIR)

[eagle32a]

I've been offered Greg Jennings for Calvin Johnson straight up. Early in the season I wouldn't have done it, but neither has got it together much and I feel that Green Bay is much more stable in the long run. It's a keeper league, so I hate giving up Megatron because of his talent. I also have and will keep Aaron Rodgers, so the QB/WR matchup is nice looking. Any thoughts?

Rest of my team:
QB - A. Rodgers
WR - R. Wayne
WR - C. Johnson
WR - L. Moore
WR - S. Holmes
RB - M. Forte
RB - F. Gore
RB - R. Williams
RB - B. Jacobs
RB - K. Moreno
RB - S. Greene
RB - M. Bell

[JavaDude]

Pull the trigger. Johnson has no one to throw the ball to him.

[tobias2]

Actually I would not do that. Calvin looked decent before he got hurt and Driver has clearly outperformed Jennings this year. Especially in a keeper, league, I'd go with megatron.

help?
viewtopic.php?t=458173

[Indibuck]

No way do I do this deal.

Megatron>>>>>>Jennings in a keeper league.

[dblj9911]

No, in a keeper league there is no chance I'm trading Calvin for Jennings. Both have been a little banged up and slowed down this year, but when healthy Johnson is a better wr by a mile. Think about the numbers he put up last year when he had 4different qb's, once Stafford is healthy, and CJ is healthy he will be fine.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=458185

[eagle32a]

Thanks guys. I passed on the trade. Needed someone impartial to help since I was a bit focused on the idea of having Rodgers and Jennings for the next several years. Megatron just has too much talent, though.

[JaysFan]

Remember that Stafford will be good as early as late this year and Detroit is improving. They also have a much better RB than GB (Grant is crap) and Megatron is such a massive talent. DON'T DO THE DEAL.

Help with mine??? viewtopic.php?t=458214