CJohnson/SSmith(NYG) for SJackson/DJackson? WHIR

[Boyakasha]

Should I send Chris Johnson and Steve Smith (NYG) for Steven Jackson and DeSean Jackson?
Leave a link, thanks!

12 team redraft, with 0.5ppr
4pts Pass TD/1pt per 25yrds
6pts other TD/1pt per 10yrds

QB: Philip Rivers
WR: Steve Smith (NYG), Brandon Marshall, Hines Ward, Terrell Owens, Kevin Walter
RB: Frank Gore, Chris Johnson, Jonathan Stewart, Jamal Lewis, LeSean McCoy, Mike Bell
TE: John Carlson
K: Nate Kaeding
DEF: San Diego

[hammertime]

Dam thats a tough one but i think i would stay pat on that one...If u did do it i could see why bi=ut i like what u got....

[Boyakasha]

bump

[paroxsitic]

Id go with the Jacksons.

DeSean Jackson has been awesome this season and I suspect it will continue. Smith is good but NYG passing schedule coming up is 2nd worse based on my analysis.

CJohnson has a better SoS but has been inconsistent, if you ignore his big 50ish point game he hasn't done crap this season. SJackson is going ot be more reliable.

[zftcg]

I agree that it's a very even trade. Two good RBs playing for bad teams, and two WRs capable of putting up big numbers (though in very different ways). I think CJ's buy low -- I can't imagine Tenn staying this bad. I think Smith is probably not as good as his first few games, but not as bad as his last few. I think SJax is basically what you've seen already. Same with DJax -- always capable of busting a big one, and I think their O has actually underperformed the past few weeks. So yeah, on balance I'd probably go with the Jacksons. But it's close.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=458713&p=3140085#p3140085

[MadDog36]

Meh, thats pretty even. I would want the players that put up the most points consistently. What sucks is that SJax's lack of TDs.

CJ4 will turn it around.

Sjax is fantasy gold though ( a good player on a bad team ).

I'd rather have DJax for the rest of the season bye a slight margin over Smith.